top of page
Search
Writer's pictureStephanie Jacobson

Fix or Forget It? The Ultimate Guide to Knowing When It’s Time for a New Car!


An Upset Man Looking at His Broken Car by MART PRODUCTION

Owning a car comes with many perks but keeping it running smoothly can become expensive over time. At some point, every car owner wonders, “Should I fix it, or is it time to forget it?” 


Whether you’re dealing with a costly repair or questioning if your vehicle is worth the investment, understanding when to stop pouring money into an old car can save you time, stress, and hard-earned cash. At Greasers Auto, we know these decisions can be tough, so we’ve put together the ultimate guide to knowing when it’s time for a new car to help you weigh your options wisely.

 

1. Assess the Car's Value vs. Repair Costs

Fix or forget it? Start by weighing your car’s current market value against the cost of repairs. Request a repair quote from a trusted mechanic, especially for larger fixes like engine or transmission repairs that can run between $2,000 and $5,000—often close to an older car’s entire value.


Imagine this: if your car is valued at $4,000 and a repair will set you back $3,500, investing in a new vehicle might make more financial sense. To assess your car's worth, check online valuations or bring it to our shop at 717 S Hacienda Dr, Tempe, AZ 85288 for a free 30-minute inspection. We'll provide honest advice to help you decide if it’s time to fix or forget it.

 

2. Look at the Car’s Age and Mileage

Cars can last for years with good care, but eventually, every vehicle reaches a point where it’s better to forget it. Repairs often escalate after 150,000 to 200,000 miles, no matter how meticulously you’ve maintained it.


If your car has high mileage or is over 15 years old, you may find yourself visiting Greasers Auto more than you’d like. While we’re always here to keep your vehicle running smoothly, we understand the need to consider if it’s time to move on to a newer model. Schedule an inspection at greasersauto.com to help determine if your car’s age is a sign to fix it or forget it.

 

3. Factor in Safety and Reliability

Safety should always come first. Older cars often lack modern safety features, and with age, reliability can suffer. If breakdowns are frequent or safety components like brakes and suspension are compromised, ask yourself: Is it time to forget it?


At Greasers Auto, we’re committed to keeping your car safe and reliable through quality maintenance. However, if you’re unsure of its roadworthiness, it may be better to fix it or forget it. Visit us for a complimentary 30-minute inspection for peace of mind.

 

4. Consider Your Future Needs

Fix or forget it? Your car should match your lifestyle. If it no longer meets your needs—like needing more room for a growing family or better fuel efficiency for a longer commute—it might be smarter to invest in a new car that does.


Think about whether your car fits your long-term goals. If it doesn’t, perhaps it’s time to forget it and look for a vehicle that can better serve your future.

 

5. Weigh Your Emotional Attachment

Sentimental value often makes it hard to let go of a car, especially one that’s been with you for years. But consider this: Fixing it for emotional reasons might not mean it’s financially wise.


If the idea of saying goodbye to your car is difficult, you could keep it as a project vehicle rather than a daily driver. That way, you can save money and still preserve the memories without constantly asking yourself if it’s time to fix or forget it.

 

6. Evaluate the Cost of a New Car

The expense of buying a new car is significant, and not everyone is ready to take on a new payment. Sometimes, repairing an older car is the most cost-effective choice. At Greasers Auto, we’re dedicated to helping you find the best option—whether that means continuing repairs or transitioning to a new vehicle.


If you’re in Tempe and want personalized guidance, contact us at (480) 946-0890 or info@greasersauto.com to discuss whether it’s time to fix or forget it.

 

7. Weigh the Pros and Cons of Fix or Forget It?

Here’s a quick breakdown to help you decide if it’s better to fix it or forget it:

Pros of Fixing Your Car:

·       Lower Initial Cost: Repairs are generally cheaper than buying a new or used car.

·       No New Car Payments: Avoid a new monthly payment by keeping your car.

·       Familiarity: You know your car’s history, quirks, and maintenance needs.

Cons of Fixing Your Car:

·       Unpredictable Costs: Repairs on older cars can be unexpected and frequent.

·       Limited Reliability: High-mileage vehicles can be less dependable.

·       Outdated Features: Older cars lack modern safety and tech updates.

Pros of Replacing Your Car:

·       Increased Reliability: Newer cars usually require fewer repairs and come with warranties.

·       Modern Features: Updated tech and safety options.

·       Better Fuel Efficiency: Many newer vehicles save you money at the pump.

Cons of Replacing Your Car:

·       Higher Initial Cost: New or used cars need a significant upfront investment.

·       Monthly Payments: Leasing or financing adds a new bill to your budget.

·       Depreciation: New cars lose value quickly.

 

Schedule a Free 30-Minute Inspection

Still uncertain? The best way to decide if it’s time to fix or forget it is by consulting a professional. Greasers Auto offers a free 30-minute inspection to evaluate your vehicle’s condition and provide unbiased advice. Book online at greasersauto.com, call us at (480) 946-0890, or stop by our Tempe location at 717 S Hacienda Dr. We’re here to help you make an informed choice that works for you.

 

Final Thoughts

Deciding whether to fix or forget it is a big decision, but with the right guidance, you can make the best choice for your situation. Greasers Auto is here to help you, whether you decide to keep repairing or move on to something new. Reach out to us anytime for advice or to book an inspection.



When your car needs fixing, there is only one place to go... Greasers Auto in Tempe, AZ - 480-946-0809

2 views0 comments

Commentaires


bottom of page